Meta, Google faces EU data outage as contract decision looms


Content of the article

(Bloomberg) – Meta Platforms Inc.’s stern warning of a pullout from Europe may be just the beginning, as one of the region’s top privacy watchdogs prepares a decision that could cripple transatlantic data flows and risk billions in revenue for tech giants.

Ireland’s Data Protection Authority, which oversees the Silicon Valley tech giants that have flocked to the country, will soon rule on the legality of so-called standard contractual clauses used by Meta, Alphabet Inc.’s Google and others to lawfully transfer entire swathes of user data to the United States for processing.


Content of the article

Privacy experts say the impending decision could eliminate one of the only remaining options for Meta and potentially thousands of other businesses that rely on shipping large amounts of business data across the Atlantic.

The Irish authority has already questioned the legality of the SCCs in an interim opinion, saying they have failed a key test of protecting European citizens from the prying eyes of US agencies.

Such is the tension around the decision, which Meta warned in its latest annual report that it will “likely be unable” to offer services such as Facebook and Instagram in the EU if it is unable to use CSCs.

Facebook generated $8.2 billion in revenue in Europe in the last quarter of 2021, around a quarter of global revenue. While the UK will account for a significant portion of this and will not be impacted by the SCC decision, the region is a serious source of revenue for Meta, beaten only by its home market of the US and Canada.


Content of the article

There is no easy workaround. Storing data in Europe may not be possible for any service based on customer interactions across the globe, from gaming to video streaming, as European data rules track a person’s information wherever they find themselves.

Meta’s business model, like Alphabet’s Google, relies on collecting enough data to discern what users might be interested in or want to buy, and to serve them relevant advertising. The company is already hobbled by European privacy rules and a ban on SCCs would likely make its business model more expensive and less efficient to run.

“What’s at stake here are all data transfers to the United States and the services that depend on it,” said Johannes Caspar, an academic who recently resigned from his post as one of Germany’s top regulators. of data protection.


Content of the article

Despite its latest comments in its annual report that it would be “probably unable” to offer Facebook and Instagram in Europe if regulators decided that SCCs weren’t feasible, Meta also said – most recently in a blog post that he was “absolutely not threatening to leave”. Europe,” a plea that Nick Clegg, now Meta’s chief policy officer, originally made in September 2020.

Meta declined to comment. Google pointed to a January blog post from Kent Walker, its head of global affairs, which called for a speedy end to the impasse over replacing an EU-US privacy pact that was overturned by the most EU’s top court in 2020 due to long-standing fears that citizens’ data was not immune from US surveillance.

“The stakes are too high – and international trade between Europe and the United States too important to the livelihoods of millions of people – not to find a quick solution to this looming problem,” he said. declared.

If the Irish authority doubles down on its provisional opinion on contract terms, the doomsday scenario for Meta and its rivals of a technology blackout has begun to emerge.

The decision by the Irish authorities “could now be a precedent that would turn the whole situation upside down”, Caspar said. “It’s up to American politicians to avoid throwing their tech industry into chaos.”

©2022 Bloomberg LP



Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively yet civil discussion forum and encourages all readers to share their views on our articles. Comments can take up to an hour to be moderated before appearing on the site. We ask that you keep your comments relevant and respectful. We have enabled email notifications. You will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, if there is an update to a comment thread you follow, or if a user follows you comments. See our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings.


About Author

Comments are closed.